The Attention Economy Has Made Everything Look the Same

Spend an afternoon on Dribbble, Behance, or any design awards site and you will notice something unsettling: the work is technically excellent and almost entirely interchangeable. The same colour palettes. The same type treatments. The same layouts. The same quiet, tasteful restraint that signals design sophistication while saying nothing in particular.

Why This Happened

The optimisation of design for engagement metrics has produced a convergence toward the aesthetic middle. Safe, polished, and inoffensive performs better in A/B tests. Rough edges get smoothed. Distinctiveness gets rounded off. The result is a landscape where every SaaS product looks like every other SaaS product, every luxury brand adopts the same spare minimalism, and every food and beverage brand reaches for the same hand-drawn imperfection.

Designers are not to blame for this. The incentive structures are. When performance data is available at every decision point, and when the definition of performance is clicks, views, and conversions, the natural outcome is convergence toward whatever the current data says performs best. The problem is that what performs best today is what was distinctive yesterday — and by the time the data confirms it, everyone has copied it.

Distinctiveness Is a Business Advantage

The brands that have built genuine long-term equity — the ones that people feel something about — are almost always the ones that made choices their competitors would not make. They picked a typeface that felt wrong at first. They used a colour that focus groups hated. They refused to follow a trend that would have made them easier to understand and harder to remember.

This requires a different kind of client relationship than most agencies have. It requires a client who trusts that distinctive does not mean alienating, and an agency that can hold that distinction under pressure. Most rebrands get smoothed out in the review process — not because anyone makes a single bad decision, but because each small act of risk mitigation adds up to something generic.

How We Think About It

The question we ask at the start of every identity project is: what would make this brand impossible to confuse with anyone else? Not different for its own sake — that is just noise. But genuinely, specifically itself.

Sometimes the answer comes from the product. Sometimes from the founder's personality. Sometimes from the customer's relationship with the category. Always, the answer comes from specificity rather than from looking at what is currently winning on the awards circuit.

A Note on Trends

Following design trends is a strategy for looking contemporary today and dated in three years. The brands built to last are the ones that look slightly wrong when they launch and completely right a decade later. That feeling of slight wrongness is usually the signal that something genuinely original is happening.